![friends season 4 episode 17 friends season 4 episode 17](https://cdn.animationexplore.com/thumbs/Thomas--Friends-Season-4-Episode-17-Train-Stops-Play.jpg)
He’s beside himself, but he and Jack go to track down William. Jack immediately makes Rebecca tell Randall the truth. The fire, however, scares Rebecca into finally telling Jack that she knows who Randall’s biological father is and has been lying about it for 17 years. And so Randall tells us a story: He yells at Jack to not go back in the burning house, so his smoke inhalation doesn’t end up giving him a heart attack, and he survives. She wants to hear how he thinks things would be different. Louis for the Alzheimer’s clinical trial, all he can think about is how his life would be different with Jack still in it. Leigh that since confronting Kevin about Rebecca going to St. Let’s run through Randall’s first Jack Survives scenario. The heart wants what the heart wants and all that. But maybe people loved it and I am a party pooper.
FRIENDS SEASON 4 EPISODE 17 SERIES
Aside from the ending, though (which was wow wow wow and we will get to it), does this episode do anything to push the plot of this series forward? I am extremely on the fence as to whether it was worth it to devote an episode to this. It’s not that I didn’t like seeing Old Jack (you guys, Jack in his sixties at Philadelphia Thanksgiving? That Jack is a Hot Jack), or watching Rebecca and Jack playing out some of these scenarios, but it all felt … a little fan service-y? A little here’s something for Milo Ventimilgia to do-y? Yes, Randall working through the best case and the worst case of what his life would look like without that tragedy hanging over him leads to a big breakthrough and an extremely complex kicker. Leigh about what he thinks his life would be like if Jack had survived the fire, angrily asks: “What is the point of this exercise?” And reader, I must admit, I was asking the same question.
![friends season 4 episode 17 friends season 4 episode 17](http://thefriends.online/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/s4e10.jpg)
Welcome to your What If Jack Never Died episode, my friends! At one point Randall, who is in a therapy session throughout most of this episode, telling Dr. Brown and Niles Fitch are both so good in this Very Randall Episode that it might make you forget your troubles for a moment, and two, This Is Us really swings big here and it is puzzling? We should talk about it. And yet, we will march on because well, for one, Sterling K. Let’s be honest: This Is Us is not exactly the best show to watch when in need of escape or comfort.